Neapolitan vs. Neo-Neapolitan vs. New York Pizza: What’s the Difference?

Close-up of a blistered, leopard-spotted Neapolitan pizza crust at Royale in Miami Beach

Ask for “pizza” and you could get almost anything. Three styles come up most often: Neapolitan, New York and neo-Neapolitan. They share a name, but the dough, the oven and the experience at the table are very different.

Neapolitan pizza: the original

Neapolitan pizza comes from Naples, where the art of the pizzaiuolo is recognized by UNESCO as part of Italy’s intangible cultural heritage.

  • Dough: flour, water, salt and yeast, stretched by hand, never with a rolling pin.

  • Bake: a very hot wood-fired oven and a bake of around 60 to 90 seconds.

  • Crust: a soft, tender center and a puffy, charred rim called the cornicione, with dark “leopard spots.”

  • Toppings: few and simple, led by the two classics, Marinara and Margherita.

  • How it’s eaten: a personal-size pie, often with a knife and fork or folded in quarters.

New York pizza: big, thin and by the slice

New York pizza grew out of Neapolitan pizza brought by Italian immigrants, then adapted to American ovens and appetites.

  • Dough: often includes oil and a little sugar, and is stretched thinner and wider.

  • Bake: a gas or electric deck oven at a lower temperature than Naples, for a longer bake.

  • Crust: crisp enough to hold a folded slice, with a firmer, more even rim.

  • How it’s eaten: large pies cut into wide slices, often to go.

A neo-Neapolitan Margherita pizza with tomato, fior di latte and basil at Royale

Neo-Neapolitan pizza: the modern take

Neo-Neapolitan is a newer, looser term for pizza that starts from the Neapolitan tradition but changes the method. Pizzaioli might use different flours, longer fermentation, different ovens or less traditional toppings, often for a crust that is a little crisper or lighter than classic Naples.

Where Royale fits: Tokyo-style neo-Neapolitan

Royale is neo-Neapolitan, shaped by the precision of Tokyo’s pizzerias. We keep what makes Neapolitan pizza great — hand-stretched dough, a blistered cornicione and exceptional Italian ingredients — and refine the method:

  • Premium non-GMO Italian flours, blended for lightness, structure and crispness

  • Miami water softened to recreate the softness of Tokyo’s

  • Dough fermented for more than 30 hours

  • A longer bake at lower heat, for an airy interior and a delicate crispness

The toppings move between Naples and Tokyo too, from a classic Margherita to The Angie Mieux, with maguro and fresh wasabi sauce.

Which one should you order?

If you want the purest taste of Naples, start with a Marinara or Margherita. If you want to taste the Tokyo side of Royale, try one of our specials. Either way, eat it within the first few minutes out of the oven, when the crust is at its best.

Find Royale Pizza Napoletana at 1680 Meridian Avenue, Suite 102, Miami Beach, just off Lincoln Road.

Previous
Previous

Marinara vs. Margherita: Naples’ Two Original Pizzas

Next
Next

Why We Ferment Our Pizza Dough for More Than 30 Hours