Marinara vs. Margherita: Naples’ Two Original Pizzas

In Naples, two pizzas come before all the others: the Marinara and the Margherita. Both are simple, both are built on tomato, and both are a true test of a pizzeria, because with so few ingredients there is nowhere to hide. Here is how they differ.

A Marinara pizza with tomato, sliced garlic and basil coming out of the oven at Royale

Pizza Marinara: tomato, garlic, oregano

The Marinara is the older of the two. It has no cheese at all: just tomato, garlic, oregano and olive oil on a hand-stretched base. The name is often linked to Naples’ seafaring past, and one popular story says it was what fishermen’s families made for the men coming home from sea. Like many food stories, it is hard to prove, but the pizza itself has been a Naples staple for centuries.

Without cheese, the Marinara is all about the tomato and the dough. You taste the sweetness and acidity of the sauce, the warmth of the garlic and the char of the crust more clearly than on any other pizza.

Royale’s Marinara ($24): Rega tomatoes, garlic, oregano, basil, Okinawa salt and extra-virgin olive oil.

A Margherita pizza with tomato, fior di latte and fresh basil at Royale in Miami Beach

Pizza Margherita: tomato, mozzarella, basil

The Margherita adds soft mozzarella and fresh basil to the tomato base. The famous story says that in 1889 a Naples pizzaiolo, Raffaele Esposito, made a pizza for Queen Margherita of Savoy in the colors of the Italian flag (red tomato, white mozzarella, green basil) and named it after her. Historians debate how much of that story is true, and similar pizzas existed before then, but the name stuck and the Margherita became the most famous pizza in the world.

Where the Marinara is bold and savory, the Margherita is softer and creamier, with the mozzarella melting into the tomato.

Royale’s Margherita ($27): Rega tomatoes, basil, fior di latte and extra-virgin olive oil.

The Royale Signature Royale Margarita pizza with shaved parmesan on top

The Royale Margherita: our signature take

For something richer, the Royale Margherita ($29) brings the two classics together: our Marinara base finished with creamy stracciatella and 18-month DOP Parmigiano.

Why the dough matters more on a simple pizza

With only a few toppings, the crust carries the pizza. Ours starts with premium non-GMO Italian flours and Miami water softened to recreate the softness of Tokyo’s. It ferments for more than 30 hours and bakes longer at a lower heat, for an airy interior, a blistered cornicione and a delicate crispness that holds up under the tomato.

Which should you order?

Order the Marinara if you want the purest taste of tomato and crust, or if you’re avoiding dairy (ask your server about any allergies). Order the Margherita if you want the classic. Ordering for the table? Get one of each and taste them side by side.

Find both at Royale Pizza Napoletana, 1680 Meridian Avenue, Suite 102, Miami Beach, just off Lincoln Road.

Next
Next

Neapolitan vs. Neo-Neapolitan vs. New York Pizza: What’s the Difference?